Talk to Orthopedic Surgeon on Fracture In Clavicle
Asking for Wife, Female, 33 years old, Karachi
My wife has suffered an accident and fractured her left clavicle. The ortho specialist said there will be no intervention, and just put a tight 8 bandage around her shoulder and instructed it to get rebandaged twice a week to make sure it remains tight. 6 weeks recovery time has been suggested. X-rays are being attached for reference. Please advice if what has been suggested is appropriate or something more needs to be done?
Dr. Irfan Ahmad Chaudhary - Orthopedic Surgeon
MBBS, FCPS (Orthopedic Surgery), Member AO Trauma (Switzerland) | Lahore
yes u have been advised appropriate, just keep ur followup with the orthopaefic surgeon
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Muhammad Bilal - Orthopedic Surgeon
MBBS, FCPS, FRCS (Orthopedics) England, Fellowship (Shoulder Surgery) UK | Lahore
115 Positive Reviews
most of clavicle fractures are treated without operation.
Bandage is usually not required.a simple polysling around shoulder for four weeks then start gentle movement.
if joint is not moved for long, it can get stiff.
Dr. Latif Khan - Orthopedic Surgeon
MBBS, FCPS (Orthopedic), Fellowship Spine Surgery (AO-Spine), Fellowship Spine Surgery (POA) | Lahore
1 Positive Reviews
I agreed with your doctor. Fracture will unite in 6 to 8 weeks.
Polysling will be suffice.... no need for figure of eight bandage
surgery not needed it should unite with time
Member
Anonymous User
If there is no displacement of fracture fragments and if there is no tenting of overlying skin then nothing further to be done
Dr. Asadullah - Orthopedic Surgeon
D.O, D.C (American Board Certified) | Lahore
we will do cold laser in this situation and earlier the better while its as acute so it can heal faster and properly.
Dr. Rizwan Ghafoor - Orthopedic Surgeon
| MBBS | FCPS (Othopedic Surgery) | | Multan
74 Positive Reviews
Simple poly sling will suffice
Asst. Prof. Dr. Hamza Fareed - Orthopedic Surgeon
MBBS, FCPS (Trauma and Orthopedics), MRCPS (Glasgow), MRCS (Edinburgh), GMC Registered (UK) | Rawalpindi
23 Positive Reviews
rightly said no need for surgery
Thnx for opinion,there are 2 xray films,no date of exposure is mentioned on them,in both xray films,there is difference in fracture reduction.How ever most of clavicle fractures r managed non operatively,so is this one also.As u said,tight 8 bandage,this is not tight but figure 8 bandage.4 weeks r sufficient to put this fracture in such bandage.If u have consulted orthopaedic surgeon,then u must follow periodically as he advised u.but y u felt the need of 2nd opinion?
Member
Dr. Dileep Kumaar: The X-rays were taken an hour after the accident took place. Both X-rays at the same time, but with different position of the hand... Need for 2nd opinion arose because someone told me that the figure 8 bandage is not needed in cases like these.
1 month ago
Member
Anonymous User
Dear Sirs, Thank you for your valuable feedback!!! Your help is much appreciated!!
Get Appointment with Orthopedic Surgeon
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Lahore
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Karachi
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Islamabad
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Rawalpindi
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Faisalabad
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Peshawar
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Multan
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Quetta
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Gujranwala
- Best Orthopedic Surgeon in Sargodha
- View All
Diseases releated to Orthopedic Surgeon
Services releated to Orthopedic Surgeon
Find the Questions asked in Other Categories
- Questions asked from Gynecologist
- Questions asked from Dermatologist
- Questions asked from General Physician
- Questions asked from Gastroenterologist
- Questions asked from Urologist
- Questions asked from Psychiatry
- Questions asked from Pediatrician
- Questions asked from Orthopedic Surgeon
- Questions asked from Ent Specialist
- Questions asked from Dentist
26 Positive Reviews